Five Star Dentistry photo 1
Five Star Dentistry photo 2
Five Star Dentistry photo 3
Five Star Dentistry photo 4
4 photos

Five Star Dentistry

Quality dental care in Pittsburgh

Closed
(412) 381-3373WebsiteUpdated Aug 19, 2026

About Five Star Dentistry

Set along East Carson Street in the heart of Pittsburgh's South Side, Five Star Dentistry is a neighborhood practice built around keeping local smiles healthy without sending patients across town for specialty work. The team handles the steady rhythm of general dentistry, from cleanings and exams to fillings and the kind of preventive checkups that catch small problems before they grow into painful ones. It is the sort of place where a working family can settle into a long-term relationship with a dentist who knows their history. When patients want to change how their smile looks rather than just how it functions, the practice leans into cosmetic dentistry. Teeth whitening can lift years of coffee and wine stains, while porcelain veneers reshape chipped, gapped, or worn front teeth into something more even and bright. These are the appointments people book before a wedding or a reunion, and the team treats them with the same care they bring to routine work. The South Side address also means the practice is ready when something goes wrong. Emergency dentistry is part of what they do, so a cracked molar or a sudden toothache does not have to wait days for relief. For patients facing missing teeth, dental implants offer a stable, lasting way to restore both chewing and confidence, and the practice can walk people through what that process looks like from start to finish. What ties it all together is a focus on comfort and clear communication. Patients who feel uneasy in the dental chair tend to appreciate a team that explains each step and moves at a humane pace. Whether someone is coming in for a simple cleaning, weighing veneers for a brighter look, or rebuilding a smile with implants, Five Star Dentistry aims to make the visit feel manageable. For South Side residents and the wider Pittsburgh community, it functions as a single, dependable place to handle nearly every dental need close to home.

On East Carson Street in Pittsburgh's South Side, Five Star Dentistry pairs everyday general care with cosmetic work like veneers and teeth whitening, and keeps room on the schedule for dental emergencies and implant cases.

Clinic Details

Insurance

Accepted

Best Known For

Dental Implants, Invisalign, Braces, Veneers, Cosmetic Dentistry

Business Hours

Monday
8:00 AM4:00 PM
Tuesday
8:00 AM4:00 PM
Wednesday(Today)
8:00 AM4:00 PM
Thursday
8:00 AM4:00 PM
Friday
8:00 AM1:00 PM
SaturdayClosed
SundayClosed

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Five Star Dentistry located?
Five Star Dentistry is a dental practice in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania (ZIP 15203).
What services does Five Star Dentistry offer?
Five Star Dentistry offers Cosmetic Dentistry, alongside routine general dentistry — checkups, cleanings, and fillings.
Does the practice treat children and adults?
Yes. Children and adults are both cared for, which makes it practical as a regular family dental home.
Can the practice handle dental emergencies?
Yes. Urgent issues — sudden pain, a cracked tooth, a lost crown — are handled through the practice's emergency dental care.
How do I book an appointment at Five Star Dentistry?
Reach Five Star Dentistry through this page to send a question or request a checkup or treatment appointment.

Location

Services Offered

Other services

Dental CrownsAffordable Dental CareDental FillingsTooth Decay TreatmentRoot Canal TreatmentDenturesBracesOrthodonticsInvisalign

Reviews

175 reviews

Smyleee Rating reflects verified profile signals, reviews, and overall care quality.

See all reviews

Recent Reviews

A
A***2 weeks ago
W
W***3 weeks ago
E
E***3 weeks ago

I haven’t been to the dentist in probably 15 years. I had a cracked molar that was causing me extreme pain. They took x-rays and explained everything to me. Unfortunately, I needed the molar extracted. I am terrified of the dentist but they led me through step by step which helped me feel confident and not as anxious. Everyone was so kind. They made sure it wasn’t painful for me. They explained throughly what I needed done going forward. It was a really good experience for not having gone so long. Thank you!

M
M***3 weeks ago

Exceptional staff. Clean environment. Parking is always easy to find.

S
S***3 weeks ago

All the ladies were super nice, and sweet. Very organized. Clean. My orthodontist did any amazing job removing my top left wisdom tooth. Quick , precise. I feel amazing. Can't wait until my next visit when I get a whitening and teeth cleaning. I've found my dental home.

L
L***1 month ago

Two weeks ago, I visited this dental office for a filling and cleaning appointment that lasted less than an hour. A few days later, I began experiencing difficulty opening my jaw, and over time it became significantly worse to the point where I could barely bite down or open my mouth fully. Because of this, I scheduled an emergency appointment. During that visit, I explained my symptoms to the dental assistant and shared concerns based on both my personal experiences and broader concerns about how patients with Medicaid insurance are sometimes rushed or dismissed in healthcare settings. Rather than listening to my concerns, the assistant immediately became defensive and brought in the office manager. I explained to him that I believed something may have gone wrong during my previous visit, specifically that the Novocaine injection may have caused an issue because I had never experienced these symptoms before and was now missing work because of it. The dentist then briefly examined me and quickly stated that it was “probably trismus” and would go away on its own. No x-ray had been taken, yet they were already making assumptions and preparing to refer me to an oral surgeon. I insisted they perform an x-ray because I did not feel comfortable accepting a diagnosis without proper testing. After I continued expressing frustration, the owner entered the room. Instead of addressing my concerns, he became defensive and dismissive. I felt he was more focused on protecting the practice than listening to a patient safety concern. As I continued advocating for myself, the owner became aggressive, got directly in my face, and told me I could leave if I continued making my statements. Only after repeatedly insisting on an x-ray did they finally perform one. The x-ray revealed that I had an abscess on an impacted wisdom tooth. What concerns me most is that if I had simply accepted their original diagnosis, I would have left with an untreated infection that could have become far more serious. The dentist attempted to diagnose me without proper imaging, my concerns were repeatedly dismissed, and the owner responded aggressively when I pushed for further investigation. I will never return to this practice. No patient should have to fight this hard simply to receive proper diagnostic care and be treated with respect when raising legitimate concerns about their health.

A
A***2 months ago

I will say, I have been to Five Star Dentistry for a year now and I have to say this was the best decision I ever made. I had years in the past as a young adult with my trauma of getting my teeth done at Nova Dental so I abandon the routines of getting my teeth done. After years of abandonment, I knew enough was enough and wanted to find a good dentistry. I stumble upon this dental clinic last year, and the 1st visit was very comforting when I told the staff my story along with the abandonment of my teeth. The staff comfort me, and gave me that day a long-term plan of work that needs to be done on my teeth. Over the previous visits, it has been lovely. The representatives at the front desk are very nice and respectful. They are always willing to work with me payment wise even when I don't have the full payment or if there is a change to my insurance. The dental/hygienist assistants are so patient and communicative with me before and during my every procedure. I also have to thank Dr. Matera (hopefully I am spelling his name right). He is quick with my procedures, always talk to me of what is going on during my procedure and so patient. I'm so thankful for Five Star Dentistry. I never felt more confident than ever when it comes to my teeth routine at home.

Q
Q***3 months ago

Upon first impression... clean and friendly. Didn't have me wait long in waiting room. Which was great! I have a toothache, Dentist came in figured out what needed done and we set a next appointment to get an extraction done. He also told me what teeth could be saved. He listened to my concerns and answered my questions. Only thing is that they didn't extract same day but He did ask me if I wanted to go to an oral surgeon to get it pulled sooner and he did give me amoxicillin to kill infection. I got an appointment a couple a weeks from now. I would say if your pain is really bad and ur looking to get it pulled asap go to Pitt emergency but if ur looking for a good dentist would highly recommend this one! Can't wait for my next appointment and to get my oral health back on track!

B
B***6 months ago

I had to have a root canal and was really anxious! The dentist was amazing, so skilled, and they went out of their way to keep me comfortable. It was painless. I’m so happy that I found this dental practice, and I recommend it without reservation!

A
A***6 months ago

I came to Five Star with my previous dentist that has since retired. Due to their convenient location I have tried to stay with them. Unfortunately, after 2 years, I have to give up and move on. The level of care is okay. However, almost every appointment I have had has been cancelled and moved due to their inability to keep hygienists. They'll reschedule appointments 5 months later - very ridiculous when one is supposed to get two cleanings a year. If you value reliability, find another dentist.

Reviews are aggregated from public sources.

Photos (4)

Five Star Dentistry photo 1
Five Star Dentistry photo 2
Five Star Dentistry photo 3
Five Star Dentistry photo 4