Nickel City Dentistry
A Hertel Avenue practice for routine restorative care
Smyleee Rating
Outstanding
About Nickel City Dentistry
Nickel City Dentistry runs a small independent practice on Hertel Avenue in the Central Park section of North Buffalo. The patient mix skews toward the families and long-time residents who live within a few blocks — Hertel is one of those streets where the dentist, the bakery, and the dry cleaner are all within walking distance, and that local feel comes through in how the practice operates. If you've been looking for a general dentist who'll know your kids by name in three years rather than rotating you through a roster, this is closer to that model than a chain.
Cavity work here is mostly routine — composite fillings for caries caught at six-month checkups, occasional larger restorations when something's been put off too long, and the bread-and-butter of general dentistry. The team uses tooth-colored composite as the default and amalgam only when a patient specifically requests it. They'll typically show you the cavity on the intraoral camera before drilling so you can see what's being treated and why, which makes the diagnostic-to-treatment handoff feel less opaque. Other services include cleanings, exams, basic crowns, and extractions.
If you've moved to North Buffalo and you're picking a new general dentist, a check-up visit here is a low-stakes way to see if the practice fits your style.
Patients searching for affordable dental fillings in Buffalo, tooth filling in Buffalo, or cavity filling near me in Buffalo tend to want a regular practice rather than one-time emergency care. Nickel City fits that — it's set up for ongoing relationships, not transactional visits. For Hertel-corridor and North Buffalo residents comparing small independent practices, this clinic belongs on the shortlist of first appointments. The visit pace tends to be slower than chain offices because the appointment book isn't padded with overlap, which means more time for actual conversation about what your X-rays show and what realistic options look like for your specific teeth and budget.
Nickel City Dentistry is a dental practice on Hertel Avenue in the Central Park area of Buffalo, New York, offering emergency dentistry and wisdom teeth removal among its listed services. The practice is open Monday through Thursday. You can reach the practice through this page to ask about treatment or request an appointment.
Clinic Details
Parking
Free street parking
Best Known For
Dental Crowns, Emergency Dental Care, Tooth-Colored Fillings, Tooth Decay Treatment, Affordable Dental Care
Business Hours
| Monday | 9:30 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 8:00 AM – 4:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 8:00 AM – 4:30 PM |
| Thursday(Today) | 8:00 AM – 4:30 PM |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is Nickel City Dentistry located?
What services does Nickel City Dentistry offer?
Does the practice treat children and adults?
Can the practice handle dental emergencies?
How do I book an appointment at Nickel City Dentistry?
Location
Services Offered
Dental Fillings
Tooth-colored fillings repair teeth affected by decay, restoring shape and function with material matched to the natural tooth.
Affordable Dental Care
Nickel City Dentistry places clear emphasis on affordable dental care, keeping routine treatment accessible for Buffalo patients budgeting for their care.
Dental Crowns
A dental crown caps a tooth that is cracked, heavily decayed, or weakened, restoring its shape, strength, and everyday function.
Emergency Dentistry
Emergency dental care addresses urgent problems such as a severe toothache, a broken tooth, or a lost filling, with prompt attention to relieve pain.
Tooth Decay Treatment
Tooth decay treatment catches and repairs cavities early, before they reach the nerve and require more involved care.
Other services
Reviews
Smyleee Rating
Outstanding
449 reviews
Smyleee Rating reflects verified profile signals, reviews, and overall care quality.
Recent Reviews
The worst dental experience I have ever had!
I had an excellent experience with my new dental office/ dental hygienist Breanne\. She was incredibly knowledgeable and paid great attention to detail throughout my appointment\. She took the time to explain everything she was doing and used wonderful metaphors that made it easy to understand my dental health and treatment\. Her pleasant, friendly demeanor immediately put me at ease, and I truly appreciated how thorough and patient she was\. She made what could have been an ordinary dental visit a positive and educational experience\. I highly recommend her to anyone looking for exceptional dental care\.
The DDS is gentle and does a good job with fillings. Thank you.
We are so glad we switched to Nickel City. The entire team from Dr Pallotta on down has been nothing but professional and very helpful. Each step of the treatments have been explained to our satisfaction and every question answered. We have been extremely happy with all the work done thus far. And, they play great music in the office!
Highly recommend! The staff were friendly and extremely knowledgeable. My hygienist, Breanne, was thorough and made sure all of my questions were answered before I left. I look forward to visiting again!
I hadn't been to the dentist in nearly a decade, and was absolutely terrified about the whole concept of dental care. Kaitlyn and Dr. Pallotta were both very kind, nonjudgmental, and helpful at getting me back on track. After a few appointments, I'm much more confident in my smile, and I know my teeth are much healthier. If you're nervous about seeing a dentist, I can't recommend them enough.
Dr. Pallotta is treating me for Invisalign and I couldn’t be happier with her treatment plan and results thus far. Kaitlyn my, hygienist did an amazing job and was very thorough cleaning my teeth resulting in a very bright smile. Highly recommend these ladies and Nickel City Dentistry.
Completely unhelpful. Did not listen to my needs. Condemned to continue existing in extreme pain. (Did NOT ask for drugs.)
Nickel City Dentistry is the BEST Dental experience I ever had! The whole team at the Hertel Avenue office was Amazing, Dr, Palotta was very compassionate and understanding of my concerns. But it all started with my phone call on Monday Alyssa, Receptionist was Amazing! When I walked in for my appt the next day Alyssa was attentive. Aamna, Dental Assistant was funny yet considerate, she really put me at ease. After seeing Dr. Falotta there was a cancellation so they had me see Kaitlyn, Hygienist, again Compassionate and understanding and explained everything thoroughly just as Dr Falotta did!! I’ve been telling everyone about this office! Thank you for being You 🫶 2/25/26 I’ve had two visits with Kaitlyn, Dental Hygienist since my initial appt on 1/6/26. Every visit from the moment I walk in and greeted by the Amazing Alyssa at the front desk makes you feel truly Welcomed and is very knowledgeable about Insurances. And as for Keen Kaitlyn, she made me feel comfortable and understood my worries, she is a very compassionate human-being. I can’t say enough about this Office, but again Thank You for being YOU 🙏💜
Very good service in and out walked in in a lot of pain and they were very attentive and was pain free in less than 5 minutes after I sat in chair this is my first visit and now my new dentist
Reviews are aggregated from public sources.
Photos (5)
Explore more
Top 10 Lists in Buffalo
Affordable Dentures and Implants in Buffalo New York
14 clinics ranked
Tooth Decay Treatment in Buffalo New York
18 clinics ranked
Gum Disease Treatment in Buffalo New York
7 clinics ranked
Kids Dentist in Buffalo New York
5 clinics ranked
Tooth Filling in Buffalo New York
16 clinics ranked
Braces in Buffalo New York
9 clinics ranked