Top 10 Tooth Filling in Madison Wisconsin

Compare Madison-area clinics on reviews, service fit, insurance, and booking convenience.

Reviewed July 30, 2026Ranking recomputed July 1, 20265 clinicsDr Maqsud Mallick, BDSHow we rank

Quick Answer

Which clinic looks strongest at a glance?

We prioritize local relevance, review strength, service breadth, access, price clarity, and patient experience signals.

At A Glance

  • Madison No Fear Dentistry is the strongest overall starting point in Madison if you want a dependable option for pediatric dentistry.
  • Associated Dentists Madison has the deepest documented patient-feedback history on this page — useful when you want the most established track record before narrowing.

Quick Summary

5 clinics scored on this page

98.6

Tap any clinic below to jump to its card and compare ratings at a glance.

Smyleee Ratings are editorial signals based on reviews, quality of care, and patient feedback. Close scores should be treated as broadly comparable.

Tooth Filling Costs in Madison, Wisconsin (2026)

Approximate price ranges — may vary by provider and insurance plan

ProcedureTypical Cost
Composite filling (small)$100 – $250
Composite filling (medium)$150 – $350
Composite filling (large)$200 – $450
Porcelain / ceramic inlay$500 – $1,500
Porcelain / ceramic onlay$600 – $1,800
Glass ionomer filling$100 – $300
Temporary filling$50 – $150
Filling replacement$150 – $400

Price ranges reflect typical Madison, Wisconsin pricing as of 2026. Actual costs vary by provider, complexity, and insurance coverage. Contact clinics directly for personalized quotes.

Prices verified Jul 30, 2026

Distance Mode

Choose how clinic distance is measured

Compare clinics either from Madison Downtown or from your live location.

Distances below are shown from Madison Downtown. Switch to From you any time.

Top Clinics in Madison Proper

Only clinics physically located in Madison appear in this primary ranking.

1

Madison No Fear Dentistry

4.9(1.2k)·8.9 km from Madison Downtown
99Smyleee

344, South Yellowstone Drive, Madison, Wisconsin

Closed · Opens Monday at 7 AM

Documented for pediatric dentistry in Madison, with dental fillings on the service list and 14 procedures on file.

Read full description

Madison No Fear Dentistry is at 344 South Yellowstone Drive in Madison, Wisconsin — on the South Yellowstone Drive corridor in west Madison, accessible from the surrounding Meadowood, Sunset Village, and West Madison residential communities. The practice name makes explicit a clinical orientation that is its defining differentiator: the explicit removal of judgment and fear from the dental visit, creating an environment where anxious or long-avoiding patients feel safe enough to seek care.

Sleep apnea treatment is listed alongside sedation dentistry and emergency dentistry — a clinical combination that reflects a practice whose patient care extends to systemic health alongside restorative and cosmetic treatment. The patient base at a No Fear Dentistry practice often includes the segment of the population that has avoided dental care for the longest — patients with severe dental anxiety, patients who have not seen a dentist in a decade or more, and patients whose dental neglect is a consequence of health anxiety rather than indifference to their oral health. Sleep apnea commonly co-presents in this demographic, and a west Madison practice that screens and manages sleep apnea via oral appliance therapy provides care that these patients would not otherwise access through conventional healthcare channels.

Sedation dentistry is central to the No Fear positioning: pharmacological management for patients whose anxiety prevents them from tolerating conventional dental treatment allows the practice to serve the most dentally anxious segment of the west Madison population. Children's dentistry is listed — the no-fear approach in paediatric dental care is particularly valuable, as childhood dental fear patterns established at early dental visits persist into adulthood and are among the most common predictors of adult dental avoidance.

Dental implants, dentures, root canal treatment, and veneers complete the restorative and prosthetic scope. Emergency dentistry handles the acute presentations that often bring long-avoiding patients through the door for the first time.

For Meadowood, Sunset Village, and west Madison patients on South Yellowstone Drive who want a general dental practice with an explicit no-fear orientation, sedation dentistry, sleep apnea treatment, and emergency care, the 344 South Yellowstone Drive address provides that combination.

Services:Dental FillingsChildren / Pediatric DentistryComprehensive Dental CareCosmetic Dentistry+10 more
Offers Dental FillingsSmyleee 99/1004.9★ · 1.2k reviews
Why this ranks
Best forDental Fillings
Why includedIncluded because this clinic directly offers Dental Fillings, 4.9★ Google rating across 1,226 verified reviews, and Smyleee Rating 99/100.
Stands outOffers Dental Fillings · Smyleee 99/100 · 4.9★ · 1.2k reviews
ProofBusiness hours publishedDirect phone numberPublic websitePrice range published14 services listed
VerifiedClinic data last verified Jul 5, 2026
2

Associated Dentists Madison

4.9(663)·6.8 km from Madison Downtown
88Smyleee

749, University Row, Spring Harbor, Madison, Wisconsin

Closed · Opens Monday at 7:30 AM

Pediatric Dentistry focus in Madison, with dental fillings listed among 18 documented services.

Read full description
When you’re looking for the best dentist in Madison, know that at Associated Dentists, you’ll find a higher standard. Family dental health is important, which is why we offer general dentistry, emergency dental care, and cosmetic dentistry to give you the smile you’ve always wanted. Keeping your teeth healthy is essential and our staff works hard to make going to the dentist a great experience for you. Our caring staff that goes the extra mile is why you should trust your dental care to us. They are what makes us different and it’s a difference you’ll notice right away when you walk in the door. Our facilities are top-notch because we want you to be comfortable with your dental visit. We use the latest technology and pay attention to the smallest details in our office to make sure you’re comfortable and happy. Your satisfaction is important to us and we’re the next Madison WI dentist you can trust with whatever dental care you need. You have a choice with Madison dentists and we know that if you give us a try for your next cleaning, emergency, or cosmetic dental need, you’ll be happy with how you’re treated, the care you get, and your entire visit.
Services:Dental FillingsChildren / Pediatric DentistryCosmetic DentistryDental Bonding+14 more
Offers Dental FillingsSmyleee 88/1004.9★ · 663 reviews
Why this ranks
Best forDental Fillings
Why includedIncluded because this clinic directly offers Dental Fillings, 4.9★ Google rating across 663 verified reviews, and Smyleee Rating 88/100.
Stands outOffers Dental Fillings · Smyleee 88/100 · 4.9★ · 663 reviews
ProofBusiness hours publishedDirect phone numberPublic websitePrice range published18 services listed
VerifiedClinic data last verified Jul 4, 2026
3

Excellence in Dentistry - Madison

4.9(375)·4.3 km from Madison Downtown
98Smyleee

1001, North Sherman Avenue, Sherman, Madison, Wisconsin

Closed · Opens Monday at 8 AM

Madison clinic with a dental implants specialty — Dental Fillings is on file among 15 procedures.

Read full description

Excellence in Dentistry is at 1001 North Sherman Avenue in Madison's Sherman neighbourhood — on the North Sherman Avenue corridor in Madison's east side, accessible from the surrounding Sherman, Emerson East, and Schenk-Atwood residential communities. The practice's stated mission is to provide proper and ethical dental treatment and to encourage patients to discuss oral health concerns in a non-judgmental environment.

The non-judgmental orientation in the practice's clinical philosophy addresses a real barrier in dental care access: patients who have neglected dental care for extended periods — due to cost, anxiety, lack of insurance, or competing life priorities — often present with shame about the state of their oral health and experience elevated anxiety about the clinician's response to dental neglect. A practice that explicitly positions itself as judgment-free for these presentations is more likely to retain the patients who most need care, creating better clinical outcomes than a practice environment where patients feel evaluated or judged for their dental history.

Oral cancer screening is explicitly listed — annual mucosal surveillance through visual and tactile examination during recall appointments. In Madison's Sherman and east side communities, where tobacco use and the risk factors associated with HPV-related oropharyngeal cancer are present, systematic oral cancer screening at each recall appointment provides early detection capability that the dental practice is uniquely positioned to deliver.

Dental sealants for paediatric preventive care, family dental care, and children's services cover the household preventive scope. Dental implants and dentures provide the prosthetic replacement range. Sedation dentistry is available for patients whose anxiety about dental care has caused them to defer treatment. Root canal treatment, periodontal care, and professional cleaning complete the restorative and maintenance scope.

For Sherman, east Madison, and Schenk-Atwood patients on North Sherman Avenue who want a family dental practice with oral cancer screening, sedation dentistry, and an explicitly non-judgmental clinical culture, the 1001 North Sherman Avenue address provides that combination.

Services:Dental FillingsDental BridgesDental CleaningDental Crowns+11 more
Offers Dental FillingsSmyleee 98/1004.9★ · 375 reviews
Why this ranks
Best forDental Fillings
Why includedIncluded because this clinic directly offers Dental Fillings, 4.9★ Google rating across 375 verified reviews, and Smyleee Rating 98/100.
Stands outOffers Dental Fillings · Smyleee 98/100 · 4.9★ · 375 reviews
ProofBusiness hours publishedDirect phone numberPublic websitePrice range published15 services listed
VerifiedClinic data last verified Jul 4, 2026
4

Isthmus Dental, Ltd

4.9(263)·421 m from Madison Downtown
97Smyleee

122, East Johnson Street, Madison, Wisconsin

Closed · Opens Monday at 8 AM

Dental Implants is the documented focus in Madison; Dental Fillings sits within 12 services on profile.

More about dental fillings at this clinic

Crown and bridge restorations and dental fillings complete the restorative maintenance scope for the East Johnson Street patient community.

Services:Dental FillingsDental BondingDental BridgesDental Crowns+8 more
Offers Dental FillingsSmyleee 97/1004.9★ · 263 reviews
Why this ranks
Best forDental Fillings
Why includedIncluded because this clinic directly offers Dental Fillings, 4.9★ Google rating across 263 verified reviews, and Smyleee Rating 97/100.
Stands outOffers Dental Fillings · Smyleee 97/100 · 4.9★ · 263 reviews
ProofBusiness hours publishedDirect phone numberPublic websitePrice range published12 services listed
VerifiedClinic data last verified Jul 4, 2026
5

Dental Health Associates of Madison - Downtown Clinic

4.9(422)·188 m from Madison Downtown
95Smyleee

201, 44, East Mifflin Street, Madison, Wisconsin

Closing soon · 4 PM

Profile in Madison flags pediatric dentistry; lists Dental Fillings alongside 25 other documented services.

Read full description

Dental Health Associates of Madison – Downtown Clinic is at suite 201, 44 East Mifflin Street in Madison — a location in the heart of downtown Madison, one block from the Wisconsin State Capitol building. Dental Health Associates of Madison was founded in 1969 by a group of five dentists who saw the clinical benefit of providing a complete range of dental services under one roof rather than as solo practitioners referring across the city. More than fifty years later, the DHA group practice model continues at this East Mifflin Street address and multiple additional Madison locations.

NightLase is listed alongside sleep apnea treatment, bruxism management, and periodontics — a distinctive clinical combination at a downtown Madison group practice. NightLase is a Fotona Er:YAG laser treatment for snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnea that contracts the soft palate tissue through controlled photothermal heating. Combined with oral appliance sleep apnea therapy, this downtown Madison practice offers multiple complementary modalities for sleep-disordered breathing — a clinical range that distinguishes DHA from single-modality sleep apnea management providers.

The multi-dentist group structure established in 1969 provides clinical depth across orthodontics, endodontics, periodontics, and paediatric dentistry within one practice — the concept Drs. Buchanan and O'Brien saw was needed in Madison's dental market half a century ago. For downtown Madison patients who work in the Capitol complex, State Street corridor, or University of Wisconsin medical campus, the East Mifflin Street location provides full-scope dental care in the city's geographic and governmental centre.

Orthodontics including braces and Invisalign, endodontics, periodontics, and sedation dentistry round out the comprehensive scope. Emergency dentistry covers the acute presentations for downtown Madison's dense workday and resident population.

For downtown Madison, Capitol Square, and State Street patients on East Mifflin Street who want a multi-specialist group practice with NightLase, sleep apnea treatment, orthodontics, and periodontics founded in 1969, DHA's suite 201 at 44 East Mifflin Street provides that combination.

Services:Dental FillingsBracesBruxismChildren / Pediatric Dentistry+22 more
Offers Dental FillingsSmyleee 95/1004.9★ · 422 reviews
Why this ranks
Best forDental Fillings
Why includedIncluded because this clinic directly offers Dental Fillings, 4.9★ Google rating across 422 verified reviews, and Smyleee Rating 95/100.
Stands outOffers Dental Fillings · Smyleee 95/100 · 4.9★ · 422 reviews
ProofBusiness hours publishedDirect phone numberPublic websitePrice range published26 services listed
VerifiedClinic data last verified Jul 4, 2026

Side-by-Side Comparison

Hard signals for every dental fillings provider on this list — no opinions, just verifiable data.

#ClinicSmyleeeGoogleWkndIns.Fin.Offers
Dental Fillings
1Madison No Fear Dentistry994.9(1,226)
2Associated Dentists Madison884.9(663)
3Excellence in Dentistry - Madison984.9(375)
4Isthmus Dental, Ltd974.9(263)
5Dental Health Associates of Madison - Downtown Clinic954.9(422)

Smyleee Rating bands: 90+ Outstanding · 84–89 Excellent · 71–83 Very Good · 61–70 Good · below 61 Rated.

How to Choose a Dentist in Madison, Wisconsin

Use the ranking as a starting point, then narrow the shortlist based on the kind of care you actually need.

If you want routine or family care

Prioritize review consistency, insurance friendliness, practical hours, and a broad general-dentistry service mix over marketing language alone.

If urgency matters

Confirm same-day capacity, after-hours guidance, and whether the clinic handles urgent restorative work in-house or refers out.

If affordability matters most

Compare financing signals, insurance notes, and the local cost guide. A higher-ranked clinic is not automatically the best value for your specific treatment.

Questions to ask before booking

  • Do you accept my insurance or offer payment plans?
  • Are you taking new patients right now?
  • Do you handle my treatment in-house?
  • What is the total expected cost before treatment starts?
EditorialUpdated July 30, 2026Independently reviewed

Madison has no shortage of dental providers — a quick search pulls up hundreds. The challenge isn't finding one, it's figuring out which ones actually deliver. We spent time reviewing patient outcomes, checking credentials, comparing pricing, and analyzing feedback from patients who've had tooth filling work done across the Madison metro area.

This is the short list. Ten providers in Madison, Wisconsin that consistently showed up in the data — not because they paid to be here, but because their patients keep coming back and referring others. If you're weighing options for tooth filling in Madison, start here.

Medically reviewed by

Dr Maqsud MallickBDS

Frequently Asked Questions

8 questions answered by our editorial team

In Madison, a composite filling typically costs $100 – $250, based on Smyleee's July 2026 local price data. Actual cost varies by provider, materials, and case complexity.
A composite filling (medium) in Madison typically ranges $150 – $350 (July 2026). Final pricing depends on the clinic, materials, and whether you have insurance.
A composite filling (large) in Madison typically ranges $200 – $450 (July 2026). Final pricing depends on the clinic, materials, and whether you have insurance.
A porcelain / ceramic inlay in Madison typically ranges $500 – $1,500 (July 2026). Final pricing depends on the clinic, materials, and whether you have insurance.
Smyleee ranks Madison dental fillings clinics on a weighted score: verified patient reviews (30%), clinical credentials and expertise (20%), technology and equipment (15%), accessibility (15%), pricing transparency (10%), and patient experience (10%). The list is recomputed from current data and independently reviewed by Dr Maqsud Mallick, BDS.
The ranking is recalculated on a rolling basis from current review and profile data and was last reviewed in July 2026. Clinics can move up or down as their underlying data changes.
Prioritise verified credentials and relevant training, modern equipment and sterilisation standards, a strong and recent review history, transparent pricing, and clear communication about treatment options. Confirm the clinic is taking new patients and offers dental fillings before booking.
Many clinics in Madison accept major dental insurance and offer financing such as in-house payment plans or third-party options like CareCredit for larger treatments. Coverage and financing vary by practice — confirm your plan is accepted and ask about phased or monthly payment options before treatment begins.

How We Vet Each Clinic

Every clinic on this list passes our verification process

  • License & standing verified — active Wisconsin dental license confirmed with no disciplinary actions.
  • Patient review volume checked — minimum verified patient reviews across Google with a strong average rating.
  • Local presence confirmed — verified physical practice in the Madison metro area with established patient base.
  • Technology & equipment assessed — modern dental technology and sterilization standards evaluated.
  • Transparent pricing reviewed — clear communication of costs, financing options, and insurance acceptance.

How We Scored the Best Clinics

Our transparent ranking methodology

Verified patient reviews & outcomes30%
Tooth Filling expertise & credentials20%
Technology investment & modern equipment15%
Accessibility (hours, location, scheduling ease)15%
Transparent pricing & financing options10%
Patient experience & comfort measures10%

How This Page Was Reviewed

We want this page to help users choose confidently, not just scroll a list.

Editorial checks

  • Locality and city fit
  • Review strength and rating consistency
  • Services, hours, insurance, and profile completeness
  • Paid placements kept separate from organic rankings

Transparency

  • Content updated: July 30, 2026
  • Ranking last recomputed: July 1, 2026
  • Medical reviewer: Dr Maqsud Mallick, BDS
  • Clinic verification dates reflect the latest synced or modified profile timestamp
  • Organic rankings are algorithmic, sponsored rows are labeled
  • Clinics can move up or down when underlying data changes

Keep comparing before you book

Use the ranking, comparison table, and nearby alternatives to narrow the shortlist that best matches your situation.

Are you a Madison clinic? Improve your profile quality, verification signals, and structured details to strengthen reconsideration for this list.